The Syfy Online NetworkSCI FI WireDVICEFidgit

We love technology. We want to know about it, write about it, and shake it till it breaks. Part of the Syfy Network, DVICE has a worldwide team of writers who constantly immerse themselves in the tech world, distilling the sometimes-excessive information out there to bring you only what you need to know.

Video
 
SHIFT: Tech In-Depth

Related Sections: Computer Peripherals  Portable Gadgets  Shift

It's time to revolt against tiny keyboards

It\'s time to revolt against tiny keyboards

Two weeks ago at Gadgetoff, a day-long conference devoted to life-changing and sometimes totally useless ideas and inventions, technology investor Gary Lauder presented an idea that captured my imagination. He spoke briefly about the history of foot binding, the practice of systematically constricting and deforming women's feet so that they would fit societal ideals. Foot binding is one of the most most extreme examples of "suffering for fashion."

Lauder then suggested that our future might include a different sort of binding: thumb binding. Right now, our opposable thumbs are just the wrong shape and size for the tiny keys on smartphones, including BlackBerries, iPhones, Palm Pres, Sidekicks and the like. But if we applied changed bandages daily the old-fashioned way, our fingers could end up in just the right shape!

This idea was obviously tongue-in-cheek — gadgets should conform to the user's hands, not the other way around. Right? Well, you wouldn't guess it from the current array of non-hand and arm-friendly keyboards I use at work and around town every day. It begs the question: Why don't we demand more ergonomic gadgets?


Are Hot Gadgets the New High Heels?

I associate the phrase "suffer for fashion" (great song, btw) with women — we don't bind our feet anymore, but we do wear high heels, even though they've been shown again and again to cause injury in the present and pain as you age. Men, it is argued, would never make such compromises just to look attractive. Their shoes are almost universally comfy.

The same cannot be said of their cellphones, PDAs, netbooks, keyboards and mice. When it comes to these gadgets, both sexes suffer the consequences for being trendy, in the form of repetitive stress injuries (RSIs), strained necks and shoulders, BlackBerry thumb and even cellphone elbow.


Fashion vs. Convenience

One might argue that we don't rely on PDAs' tiny keys because they're super cool, but because they're convenient, and that gadget makers are doing the best they can with the technology available. Tiny keyboards certainly are handy to carry around. But there are alternatives that could be just as portable and easy to use (more on this in a bit). I believe that a lot of what keeps us from adopting more comfortable, less injurious technologies is not simply convenience, but the fact that the current alternatives to tiny keys just aren't fashionabe.

Consider the lowest-hanging fruit: cellphone elbow, the pain of which I've experienced myself on occasion. Using a headset can easily prevent cellphone elbow. But headsets aren't cool. Bluetooth headsets have caught on somewhat in the suit-wearing crowd, but most of my friends wouldn't be caught dead using one even if they're comfortable (or built into your phone).

Typing is a more difficult issue. I've written most of this essay using my right hand only, because my left wrist and hand are having a painful flare-up after too much typing on crummy keyboards over too many weeks. Some QWERTY keyboards are more comfortable than others, but computers today still come standard with keyboards and mice that are terrible for our hands.

There's nothing groundbreaking or complex about ergonomic keyboard technology: It wouldn't cost companies more to make the baseline templates for both more ergonomic. Think of how much money Apple spent to design its Mighty Mouse. It's beautiful, of course, but it doesn't come close to conforming to the shape of an average human hand. In the same vein, this attractive little mouse from Microsoft may impress your friends with its looks, but your wrst may not be quite so enthusiastic. If we were begging for more and better ergonomic keyboards, companies would provide them, but as with cellphone earpieces, one major problem is that what's comfortable isn't usually what's attractive.

Another alternative to uncomfortable keyboards is to eschew typing entirely in favor of talking. Voice-recognition software is pretty great already, and it just keeps getting better — why do we use keyboards at all anymore, at least in private? Dictating to secretaries used to be expensive and inconvenient, so we've become accustomed to thinking with our fingers, but it's something we could re-learn with minimal effort. Dictating e-mails onto an iPhone in public may sound ridiculous in theory, but is it really any worse than talking on the phone to a friend? Better in-gadget dictation software would alleviate some of the damage we do to our hands while Twittering and texting.

For times when speaking out loud just isn't an option, tiny keys still aren't the only solution. laser-projection keyboards, though imperfect, are highly portable and connect to most PDAs so you can type emails on any surface. And what about good old-fashioned Palm-style writing with a stylus? It's not super fast, but then again, neither is hunting and pecking on the Palm Pre. In these days of swiping fingers and capacitive touchscreens, handwriting may be the most retro, least-trendy writing methd of all. But it does show that if companies were really driven by their customers to come up with alternatives to typing, they could.


A Shiny Future, or a Healthy One?

Gadgets are inherently kind of dorky, but it turns out there are levels of dorkiness. There's going out and getting the iPhone as soon as it hits stores (acceptably nerdy) and then there's walking around with a headset so you can dictate e-mails (unacceptably nerdy). I think we should embrace tech methods that are healthier. As we do, companies will have better incentives to develop cooler toys that don't ruin your hands. If we don't, we could well end up in an age where we distort our bodies to fit gadget fashion trends by, say, binding our thumbs to make them pointy.

 
Send-A-Friend
(8) COMMENTS

lostcarpark:
The current spate of tiny screens and keyboards on mobile devices is just a temporary glitch until we figure out ne...More »


Comments

By NunquamSecutus at 8:49 PM ON 10/15/09

Seems chordal keyboards would be a good option for hand held devices. Honestly, I find it odd that it hasn't been tried before.

By MyCaption_Team at 11:52 PM ON 10/15/09

Ultimately, a combination of gestures and voice recognition will be the ubiquitous solution for communicating with smartphones, because that's how we communicate with other humans. But it will take re-orienting our minds to compose a message in our head before speaking. With keyboards, we have become used to the idea of ready-fire-aim, since there is always the Delete key to help us rewrite before we press the Send key. In a spoken message, you have to go back to ready-aim-fire, the way it was in the days of the typewriter.

By grammarsocialist at 3:02 AM ON 10/16/09

Now you know, and knowing is half the battle.

By IntelKnight at 9:37 AM ON 10/16/09

Ergonomic keyboards and cell phone headsets have been on the market for ages, so do not blame the companies - they would love to sell you new gadgets. It's just that nobody wants to buy them.

But do not worry, creative destruction will take care of small keyboards just as it did with secretaries and numerical keyboards (1=abd, 2=def, etc.). I bet we will get to direct brain interface (via a very dorky circlet) before too long.

By Traveler at 12:16 PM ON 10/16/09

Dump the useless junk, keep the useful thumbs.

By BooDuh at 9:41 PM ON 10/16/09

I want my full-sized keyboard and a cellphone the size of a full-sized keyboard. :-)

By BigThumbs at 1:21 AM ON 10/17/09

Manufacturers like RIM and Apple are very conservative and try to squeeze the 10 keys of qwerty keyboard onto small devices - take a look at Swype, Shapewriter, AgileText and Fitaly as alternative text entry methods

By lostcarpark at 6:35 PM ON 10/22/09

The current spate of tiny screens and keyboards on mobile devices is just a temporary glitch until we figure out neural interfaces. Soon we'll be able to pluck information straight from the brain - much more efficient!


Leave a Comment


Type the characters you see in the picture above.

(Please be patient, it may take a moment for your comment to appear.)

DVICE continues below
Get the latest tech news
on your cellphone!
Text DVICE to 72434
DVICE on your iPhone
Follow DVICE on Twitter
Editor: Peter Pachal
editor@dvice.com
©2009, Syfy. All rights reserved.