The Syfy Online NetworkSCI FI WireDVICEFidgit

DVICE: We love technology. We want to know about it, write about it, and shake it till it breaks. Part of the Syfy Network, DVICE has a worldwide team of writers who constantly immerse themselves in the tech world, distilling the sometimes-excessive information out there to bring you only what you need to know.

Video
 

Related Sections: Internet  Shift

SHIFT: Is Obama a tech friend or foe?

obama_techff.jpgDVICE writers take a closer look at the latest tech trends in our weekly column, Shift.

While President Barack Obama's honeymoon rages on, those of us who like to see technological progress are keeping a close eye on the horizon, looking for either dark clouds or silver linings.

So far we're seeing a mixed bag. During the 2008 presidential election campaign, Obama sang the praises of technological progress, but some of his appointees aren't singing from the same hymnal.

At stake is the unfettered Internet, unlimited bandwidth, file sharing without government snoops breathing down our necks, and freedom to record what we want on our own DVRs. All of it could be at risk as some of the new officials move into their high offices in the Obama administration.


Questionable Appointees

The president has the final say in whatever decisions are made, but he could be influenced by his appointees, some of whom have repeatedly proven that they're no friends of technological progress. That's stoking our techno-fears.

First on the list is Vice President Joe Biden. Obama's VP has a long history of aligning himself with the recording industry. At one point he wanted to make it a felony to create a device capable of circumventing copy-protecting DRM (digital rights management).

Then there's the Department of Justice. Industry watchdogs say associate deputy Donald Verrilli and associate attorney general Tom Perrelli are "the RIAA's favorite lawyers." Add to them Neil MacBride, who before he was appointed associate deputy attorney general, was vice president of anti-piracy and general counsel at the Business Software Alliance (BSA). He headed up the practice of paying off people who report suspected software piracy to that organization. This is not looking good.

If Obama appointed these recording and movie industry advocates, who might he choose as head of the Federal Communications Commission? Former FCC chair Kevin Martin rejected the Motion Picture Association of America's (MPAA) scheme to put recording blocks onto every DVR in the country. Now that Martin's gone, the MPAA is back knocking on the FCC's door, trying to put the squeeze on temporary FCC chairman Michael Copps. Will the FCC cave, letting the MPAA decide what we can record on our own TiVos? Will Obama appoint an FCC chairman who fights for the rights of Internet service providers, or for the users of those services?


Friends of Progress

Despite those questionable appointments, all is not lost, tech lovers. There's some good news, too. For instance, when California Senator Dianne Feinstein tried to slip in a provision for "network management," allowing Internet service providers to filter broadband streams looking for copyrighted materials under the guise of protecting us from child porn, the idea was shot down before it could slither into the stimulus bill.

More good news: The economic stimulus bill's $9 billion to fund wireless broadband networks in under-served areas was on its way toward oblivion, but after all the haggling was done, the cash ended up staying in, albeit at a diminished $7.2 billion. Someone must have agreed with Robert Atkinson, president of the Information Technology and Innovation Foundation, who said a $10 billion broadband stimulus would create 498,000 new jobs. Good call.


The President's Say

There have been boatloads of alarm spread all over the Internet this past week about the diminishing role of tech in the economic stimulus bill, and most of that alarm turned out to be overwrought. The tech-smart and BlackBerry-carrying President Obama craves consensus, so he's not going to make it easy for file-sharing pirates to swipe movies and software, nor is he going to allow broadband providers to suck the life out of our crucial information conduits.

Let's hope the new president keeps a close eye on some of these record-industry and movie-business appointees of his, making sure that his fondness for Net neutrality and tech freedom isn't stomped down by greedy industry insiders who suddenly find themselves drunk on power.

 
Send-A-Friend
(8) Comments

sinfire:
i just cant stand liberals who feel the government should have no control over the internet, i mean, its not like t...More »


Comments

By Akito38A at 2:40 AM ON 02/20/09

man the government always uses the same old "We are looking for child porn" excuse to allow them to spy on users for all sorts of things.

By SvenKyUm at 1:17 PM ON 02/20/09

AKITO38A be careful what you say, that could be interpreted as an admission of guilt.

What do you have to hide? X_X
So what if the government knows what you said to/about another civilian. It is trivial, and not as invasive as you think. :P

By drake at 3:09 PM ON 02/20/09

@SVENKYUM, so what? How about its amounts to a warrant-less search and is unConstitutional for one.

When the government is given (or simply takes) this kind of power, they inevitably start using it in ways that are dangerous our rule of law. Journalists, whistleblowers, politicians, and corporate VIPs are the first to be directly targeted (and could face anything from political pressure, to intimidation, to threats on their life), followed by everyone else.

This just came out a couple weeks ago. Bush was having the NSA spy on JOURNALISTS specifically, and everyone else just for the heck of it:
http://rawstory.com/news/2008/Whistleblower_Bushs_NSA_targeted_reporters_0121.html

By IsoTek at 11:37 PM ON 02/20/09

@Drake...That guy basically made up that story, he is yet another with some beef against Bush that simply wants to smear him with no evidence. He was approached by a reporter to back up his assertions and sat there waffling about the allegations he made on camera. Anyone can say anything and if you simply hate Bush than anything bad in his name is just patently true I guess.

By Akito38A at 2:24 AM ON 02/21/09

SvenKyUm I would rather not let the government have access to all sorts of information so they can blackmail people. maybe someone didnt do something illegal but they find things that may be frowned by society and use it to blackmail people.

Its down right foolish to let them do whatever they want in the name of national security or shutting down child porn sites. Freedom comes with a price.

By Polar Waffles at 3:23 AM ON 02/21/09

"Those who sacrifice liberty for security, deserve neither"

-Benjy.

By Al at 11:40 AM ON 02/23/09

"The price of freedom is eternal vigilance." - Jefferson

Unfortunately, I'm fairly sure our leaders have been asleep at the wheel for decades.

"When you don't know where you're going what's the matter who steers?" - Moranis

By sinfire at 11:43 AM ON 03/04/09

i just cant stand liberals who feel the government should have no control over the internet, i mean, its not like the created it, oh wait, they did, the internet is just as public as the streets we drive on, or at least high traffic sites are, i can understand having privacy when you check your email, but when you surf google, freedom does come at a price, oh, and to all you people who claim that the gov is gonna blackmail you, get over it, your not as big of a deal as you think you are that the government doesnt care what xbox cheats your looking up, i cant think of a single logical scenario where the government would try and blackmail a civilian, most civilians dont have anything to offer, its just too much of a hassle.


Leave a Comment


Type the characters you see in the picture above.

(Please be patient, it may take a moment for your comment to appear.)

DVICE continues below
Get the latest tech news
on your cellphone!
Text DVICE to 72434
DVICE on your iPhone
Follow DVICE on Twitter
Editor: Peter Pachal
editor@dvice.com
©2009, Syfy. All rights reserved.