The Syfy Online NetworkSCI FI WireDVICEFidgit

We love technology. We want to know about it, write about it, and shake it till it breaks. Part of the Syfy Network, DVICE has a worldwide team of writers who constantly immerse themselves in the tech world, distilling the sometimes-excessive information out there to bring you only what you need to know.

Video
 

Related Sections: Apple  Cellphones  Google  Tech In-Depth  iPhone

SHIFT: Android — iPhone killer after all?

android_iphone.jpg

At my poker game last week, I was showing off the T-Mobile G1 Android phone. While fondling it, one of my opponent friends asked me, "Are all cellphones going to be touchscreen?" Without hesitating (or thinking) I said, "Yes," which is, of course, a stupid answer.

My initial gut reaction and ultimately nonsensical conclusion was stoked by having played with the first Android phone, the T-Mobile G1, for the last couple of weeks. My first impressions were, one, great operating system, two, bad phone, three, bad network. T-Mobile and HTC, which makes the G1, also missed some major opportunities to surpass the iPhone.

As such, as I opined last month, the G1 is not going to be an iPhone killer, which was the unspoken next question by my opponent friend. I stand by this opinion. The iPhone's dominance will not be threatened by the G1. But it will be threatened and overwhelmed by other Android phones. Click continue to see why.

Now that I've had some time to play and appreciate Android, it's obvious that the G1 is the wrong ship and T-Mobile the wrong ocean for Google to challenge Apple. In fact, future Android phones won't even need a touchscreen to beat iPhone.

It's the OS, Stupid
Unlike iPhone (the OS, not the phone), Android is flexibly designed to run on both touchscreen and non-touchscreen cellphones. All Android phones have to have Home, Menu and Back buttons and some sort of navigation control, which means less work to adapt Android to existing phone designs.

Since Android doesn't need to be touched, it's likely to show up on so-called "feature" phones. That means a lot more phones running Android vs. Apple's single iPhone model. Not right away, of course, but I'll bet we'll see a non-touch Android phone by the end of next year.

No single Android phone is likely to sell as well as iPhone. But it's quite likely that all phones running Android could surpass iPhone in sales. To warm the cockles of Eric Schmidt's heart, however, there need to be a lot more Android phones.

Android Carrier No. 2?
The G1 has been on sale for less than two weeks. That means it's time to start speculating about the next Android phone. So from which carrier will it come?

Sprint CEO Dan Hessen's recent curmudgeonly anti-Android remarks may seem to contradict reports that Sprint will be the second carrier with an Android phone. But Hesse is no doubt defending a potential sales hit to the carrier's Instinct iPhone alternative should Sprint's true Android intentions be revealed too soon.

But in the same breath, Hesse admits Sprint would have an Android phone next year. Smart money says sooner rather than later. A Sprint Android phone would be far more successful than the G1. For one thing, Sprint has more customers — and more customers interested in higher-end phones — than T-Mobile does. Sprint's 3G network is also far more ubiquitous now than T-Mobile's will be even a year from now. On top of that, Sprint also is likely to learn from G1's drawbacks when dictating design of its Android device.

Android Phone No. 2?
So who will make Sprint's Android phone, and what will it look like?

My guess: It'll be made by HTC and it will look like HTC's TouchHD. HTC has forged a strong relationship with Google with the G1. Sprint has a solid relationship with HTC as well. So, I'm going to go out on a limb and say Sprint's first Android phone will come from HTC.

HTC obviously will have learned from the G1's shortcomings. To compete with iPhone, HTC is going to not only apply some lipstick on the G1 pig, but boost its functionality as well. The TouchHD has everything the G1 lacks and some things the iPhone lacks. The TouchHD has a 3.8-inch screen, .3 inches larger than the iPhone. It has a 5-megapixel camera vs. iPhone's 2MP and the G1's 3MP imager. The TouchHD has video recording, infamously missing from iPhone and the G1. It has Wi-Fi, missing on a feature shared by the G1. It's also the first HTC phone with a 3.5mm headphone jack, unconscionably missing from the G1. The TouchHD, however, is missing a QWERTY keyboard. But the G1's QWERTY is awkward to use, so maybe a QWERTY-less Android phone isn't a bad thing.

Even if Sprint's Android phone doesn't come from HTC and doesn't resemble the TouchHD, you can be sure it'll improve on the G1 and include many of the aforementioned attributes. Technology marches on.

Economies of Android Scale
But it's not only about added functionality and aesthetics. In order for Android phones, touchscreen or not, to be dominant, they have to be priced right.

Following the usual gadget evolution and economies of scale, touchscreen phones will soon reach near price parity with non-touchscreen phones. Wal-Mart just got the ball rolling by discounting the G1 by $30, selling it for $148.88. There are rumors that Apple will slash the iPhone to $99 (there are also rumors that Apple is readying a 32 GB iPhone for the spring that could maintain the $199 price tag).

So imagine shopping for a phone a year from now. iPhone, Android phones are exactly the same price as suddenly antiquated non-touchscreen flip, slider and candybar models. Which would you buy?

Hmmm. Maybe my gut instinct about all phones being touchscreen one day isn't so off after all.

CORRECTION: The original version of this post erroneously said the G1 doesn't have Wi-Fi. In truth, it does feature the wireless technology. DVICE apologizes for the mistake.

 
Send-A-Friend
(11) COMMENTS

blues:
It's the app store. The one with more and better applications will win. Right now iphones has 10,000 apps. Most of...More »


Comments

By kaixabu at 7:03 PM ON 10/30/08

There is also the SE X1. Looks great so far. http://www.sonyericsson.com/x1/index.aspx?en-us#/product/1/1/

By Cleric at 8:26 PM ON 10/30/08

G1 has wifi

By Yujkivajra at 12:55 AM ON 10/31/08

"It has Wi-Fi, missing on the G1." CLERIC is right, the G1 DOS have Wi-Fi. I use it all the time.

By EricB at 2:01 AM ON 10/31/08

Just Get you an M88 or T32 GPS phone, from "FactoryMobilePhones.com" there better.

By DAVEDMA at 9:08 AM ON 10/31/08

I have a G1 now. Just got it last night, still wondering if I like it better then My T-Mobile Wing or not. It does have a few features that are better then the Wing but still leaves a bit to be desired. I am a little upset that you can't sync it to your outlook for contacts. That was a big feature I liked. I could wipe the phone out if needed and I got all my contacts back with no problems. I do like the ease of use on the G1. As far as the IPhone (an ipod with a phone added), I personally dont like apple and will never use any of thier products. I dont like that they have exclusive rights to thier products and the companies that sell them can't even work on them. As far as I am concerned any phone I get from T-Mobile is 100x better then the IPhone. Just my opinion.

By zephyrstarfields at 9:56 AM ON 10/31/08

To say that Android will be an iPhone killer is incorrect if you are going to count Android phones that compete in a market the iPhone does not. While the price drops of the iPhone 3G certainly make it a more competitive phone for everyone, the required data plan and plethora of "smart phone" features prohibit it from ever being a phone that everyone will use.

Further, the iPhone is unlikely to ever be given away by AT&T with a 2-year contract any time soon the way many Android phones will one day. In their creation of Android, I always got the feeling that Google was aiming for the rather large chunk of the cell phone market that Apple wasn't targeting and hoping that if they could get a small slice of the "smart phone" market at the same time, then it'd be a big boon.

It'll be interesting to see the features that both companies add due to the competition however. The way I see it, Android is the best thing to happen to the iPhone as it provides real competition. However, until a phone manufacturer can figure out how to get around Apple's patents on the iPhone to do real multi-touch and get the same sort of feeling out of their hardware, it won't matter what Android can do in the "smart phone" market.

That said, if I had a chance to get a cheap, Android-based phone for my kids to use until they're mature enough for an iPhone, I'd do it in a heartbeat.

By Unique Gift Ideas at 12:53 PM ON 10/31/08

I am definitely interested in seeing the evolution of the Android OS. Keep us updated here on DVICE of any new news! Thanks

By kschroppe at 4:04 PM ON 11/03/08

Hey what about the Touch pro it has a qwerty keyboard that works well and slides out.

By Reddy5 at 4:16 PM ON 11/05/08

Hmm... I'm not sure about touchscreens after having used my Touch Diamond (http://www.mypocketpcmobile.com/FullReviewHTCTouchDiamond/tabid/247/Default.aspx) for the past few months, I'm wondering if the Pro with its slidy keyboard would be better?

In any case, I wouldn't touch the iPhone with a bargepole - haha!

What do you guys think about the Touch Pro?

Thanks, Red

By MORK at 1:42 PM ON 11/28/08

CLERIC, that's why the words "missing on" were on strikethrough.

By blues at 5:43 AM ON 12/13/08

It's the app store. The one with more and better applications will win.

Right now iphones has 10,000 apps. Most of them are simple though. Will Android catch up and providers deeper apps? Let's see...

As a developer, I can say Android sdk is much better. And google is more user friendly. And the source code is open (G1 device is native programming locked though). But the market is much smaller comparing to iPhone, which still not much attractive to developers to jump into.


Leave a Comment


Type the characters you see in the picture above.

(Please be patient, it may take a moment for your comment to appear.)

Get the latest tech news
on your cellphone!
Text DVICE to 72434
DVICE on your iPhone
Follow DVICE on Twitter
Editor: Peter Pachal
editor@dvice.com
©2010, Syfy. All rights reserved.