The Syfy Online NetworkSCI FI WireDVICEFidgit

DVICE: We love technology. We want to know about it, write about it, and shake it till it breaks. Part of the Syfy Network, DVICE has a worldwide team of writers who constantly immerse themselves in the tech world, distilling the sometimes-excessive information out there to bring you only what you need to know.

Video
 

Related Sections: Apple  Cellphones  Lists  iPhone

5 things Apple forgot to put into iPhone 3G

iphone3g_bite.jpg

The new iPhone has some sweet new features. As an iPod owner, I can say that a 3G network connection, GPS, and a headphone jack that isn't completely ridiculous are great additions to an already impressive gadget, and will go a long way to swaying me toward getting one. But let's be honest — we all had a wish list of stuff we wanted to see in the iPhone the Sequel, and it's doubtful everyone was satisfied. Hit the Continue jump for a list of the Top 5 features Apple left out of its newest toy (and don't forget to check out the 5 things we like most about it).

1. Cut and Paste
Every iPhone owner has at some point wanted to snip part of an e-mail or text message and paste it into a browser or note. If it weren't for the iPhone's already impressive ability to recognize URLs, phone numbers and e-mail addresses, this would be crippling. More apps, however, means more ways to miss this crucial feature of all modern operating systems.

2. Haptic Feedback
Having the screen vibrate slightly when you touch it would do wonders for being able to operate the iPhone while it's in your pocket. I mean does Steve Jobs pull his iPhone out every time he wants to switch songs while riding the subway? Oh, wait a minute…

3. Flash Compatibility
This is the albatross that's holding back the mobile Safari browser from acting like a real browser. When you can't see websites like, well, SCIFI.COM, you start to feel like you're surfing the Net in 1998.

4. A Better Camera
It's always stunned me that the iPhone, one of the best portable video players I've ever seen, has a camera that can't capture video. A flash (for still pics) wouldn't hurt either, and certainly wouldn't drain the battery more than that 3G connection.

5. Wireless Modem Capabilities
The problem with wireless modems — special cards that you plug into your laptop for access to the Net via a cellphone network — is simple: They cost too damn much. That's why it's great that some phones can share their Internet access with laptops letting you piggyback on their networks (that you're already paying to access) via a wireless Bluetooth connection between the phone and laptop. With the new iPhone's 3G tech, it seems like a natural to double as a wireless modem, but Apple's kept the iPhone's Bluetooth technology firmly grounded in 2005, only allowing an audio connection with wireless headsets.

 
Send-A-Friend
(23) Comments

BroLouieLLB1:
that is why i did not switch to iphone, it is cool, but you cant use it as a modem....More »


Comments

By hiptobesquare at 8:48 PM ON 06/09/08

The haptic feedback would require more hardware.

Aside from that, these are all software features.

Cut and Paste is a software issue, as is a wireless modem function. The wireless modem function may be at issue with the goal for the iPhone to be always available to receive calls, as long as it is powered on.

It would certainly be nice for them to add that, though.

Adobe is rumored to be working on implementing flash capability, and is likely in high demand, and also likely forthcoming.

I would not say no to a higher-quality camera... but video capture is a software issue. The camera feature shows a live feed up to the point of picture capture. If it can do that, it can capture video by recording it to a file. The processor is at least as powerful, if not much moreso than other phones that encode video. It is a matter of software functions.

One thing that no one seems to mention, is Stereo Bluetooth music playback. It is ridiculous for a phone with built in bluetooth, which is Bluetooth 2.0 capable, that is also essentially, a very good iPod, to be limited with a wire or a speakerphone speaker to playback music.

Again, it is likely OS software that limits that functionality. I agree that it is very glaring for these functions to be left off, but here's hoping that the software update for 2.0 has some or preferably ALL of these functions, and they just haven't been touted in today's keynote.

By SnowDog at 12:41 AM ON 06/10/08

Let me add another couple of software holes that Apple has ignored:

1) For PC users, it requires the use of Microsoft Outlook (which I had to purchase/upgrade and embrace for sync of contacts). Seems like a basic understanding of MAPI would benefit them as some prefer Mozilla. Heck, I'll go as far as saying that it should be able to sync live over the 'net with GMAIL or other web services that offer address book sync. and other groupware features.

2) Even though they force you to embrace Outlook, there is no task list or notes sync so you get only a subset of the features and functions.
Apple has gone to great lengths to integrate with MS Exchange Server but with only the basics (Mail, Calendar, Contacts). Absence of tasks list and notes sync prevents it from being truly enterprise-class.

When will these things happen? Maybe next month, maybe never. Apple is always tight-lipped. One thing is sure, they will have to embrace the whole of a solid groupware stack if they are to gain as much momentum as they'd like in the enterprise space.

By SnowDog at 12:47 AM ON 06/10/08

Forgot to mention in my last post that even though the device (My current iPhone is a 1st gen 8GB) is a little lacking, the ease of use and other features make it a great tool that has become indispensable to me in my business and daily life. I still give it high marks overall.

By macgasm at 2:29 AM ON 06/10/08

The iPhone as a wireless modem is a pretty damn good idea. It wouldn't be too hard now, and I think there's quite the market for it. 2,3,4 are a little bit more complicated I think. Flash has nothing to do with software, and everything to do with "competition". Cut/Paste should have been addressed in version one. ;)

By dringdring at 4:19 AM ON 06/10/08

Why would Apple make the iPhone a wireless modem, when all of the not so ancient Apple laptops have built in wireless functionality?

By Igor Schwarzmann at 4:33 AM ON 06/10/08

They didn't forget 3.) - that one is on purpose.

By kl at 7:23 AM ON 06/10/08

I don't miss Flash. You lose some sites on one hand, but you don't get annoying "punch the monkey" ads on the other.

Some sites/ads can noticeably slow down multi-Ghz desktop computers - I don't want them heating-up my phone.

It's been said thousand times, even before iPhone existed, that basing site on flashy prioprietary technology is stupid. Probably sooner sites will give up and switch to "ajax" and whatnot rather than iPhone gets Flash.

By EnOne at 8:59 AM ON 06/10/08

As much as I dislike the iPhone, the flash issue is not their fault and has been created by Adobe. They have only released the most current Flash 9 SDK for Apple and Windows OSes, and still have everyone else, Linux, iPhone, Wii, PSP on version 7.

By futuredead at 12:36 PM ON 06/10/08

DringDring: Because. WIFI is different than "wireless" modem. If I'm in a place with no WiFI, but I have a cell signal I can share the Cell phones net connection with my macbook.

By raar at 1:03 PM ON 06/10/08

ENONE: There have been newer versions than flash 7 for linux for years now.

By Geekner at 3:36 PM ON 06/10/08

Tethered wireless internet access will definitely not be included as long as cell carriers have any say in it.

First, cell companies make outrageous amounts of money on the wireless internet card+service combo.

Second, they sell "unlimited" internet access for iPhones based on estimated bandwidth use. If you tether to your notebook, odds are you will use much more bandwidth than you would otherwise. They could separate phone bandwidth usage and tethered usage, like they do on some carriers, but it would create complications and dissatisfied customers.

As for the other features, I'm surprised that cut/paste and stereo bluetooth are not supported. Cut and paste is pretty much required.

The hardware has full bluetooth support, so implementing a stereo bluetooth profile is pure software work. Hopefully they will add that after launch.

By Jordan Lund at 5:10 PM ON 06/10/08

The problem with Flash has nothing to do with Apple... Adobe will only license Flash 7.0 for mobile devices. This is why Apple came up with their own YouTube browser for iPhone 1.0 (YouTube requires Flash 8.0).

Nintendo has this same problem with the Wii, the only version of Flash that works with their custom version of the Opera browser is 7.0.

Until Adobe decides to get off their bum and license the current version of Flash (9.0) for these devices they will all be limited.

By whateva at 11:20 PM ON 06/10/08

@geekner, do you know that ATT allows tethering on its other 3G smartphones (Blackjack, Blackjack2, Tilt, etc etc)? And you can tether and talk on the phone at the same time? All for no extra charge.

I think Apple just isn't smart enough to work it out. Fortunately the jailbreak community will get a nice tethering solution out pretty soon now that we have 3G.

By Sudilos at 11:07 AM ON 06/11/08

Didn't people hack/unlock the iphone 1.0 and write their own apps. Like better dialers and the such. It's clear the hardwares there, maybe someone will make some great killer underground apps for this. Allowing bluetooth 2.0 full function, video capture, and the like.

By happilycoupled at 1:09 PM ON 06/11/08

thanks to third-party software and programmers, as well as companies like DreamCatcher - who launched the iPhone Video Recorder: http://iphonevideorecorder.com iPhone owners can have more features. Otherwise, the stranglehold of Steve Jobs would keep us in the Dark Ages, having almost what we need, but always hungering for what we should have had.

By happilycoupled at 1:39 PM ON 06/11/08

Plus...this is not so much a specifically iPhone thing (but, on the other hand, it kind of is)... Both the former Cingular & the present AT&T give discounts to the military on their service and on the purchase of all phones. I had an HTC mobile device before and got the discount. When I switched to the iPhone, I was told that under Apple, they do not allow a discount on the service or the phone. This is the agreement. I did not enter the military to get handy discounts. I wanted to serve my country, but I've always been appreciative of businesses who extend these offers to us. Clearly Apple has told us where it stands.

By happilycoupled at 1:40 PM ON 06/11/08

Plus...this is not so much a specifically iPhone thing (but, on the other hand, it kind of is)... Both the former Cingular & the present AT&T give discounts to the military on their service and on the purchase of all phones (except the iPhone). I had an HTC mobile device before and got the discount. When I switched to the iPhone, I was told that under Apple, they do not allow a discount on the service or the phone. This is the agreement. I did not enter the military to get handy discounts. I wanted to serve my country, but I've always been appreciative of businesses who extend these offers to us. Clearly Apple has told us where it stands.

By mrwug at 5:59 PM ON 06/11/08

Did they add voice dialing to the 3G iPhone? I can't believe that I'm the only one who finds that feature indispensable. I love the fact that I can place a call without taking the phone out of the bag or pocket where it resides.

By dancesonsnow at 4:56 AM ON 06/14/08

I haven't tried programing with the iPhone SDK yet, but could people use the SDK to make cut/paste and Flash Plug-in's?

By obsydianenjal at 3:01 PM ON 06/14/08

I'm tired of people complaining about the same thing over and over again. First of all, how the hell is cut and paste suppose to work on my iPhone? What knit of complicated solution do u want to try and make this happen? Second, really and truely haptic feedback is not that important. I've loved this phone and the keyboard since I got it six months ago. As long as u know how to type with your thumbs you're good. The one thing I would fix is the dictionary while you're typing cause this thing comes up wit all kinds of crazy words to complete my sentences with. FLASH IS BAD DESIGN. PERIOD! I cant argue with a better camera, it takes better pix than a lot of my friends' phones but there have been ones when I would have loved to take video or needed to zoom in etc. I don't need this phone to be a modem for me because I already do all of surfing on it. Why am I gonna take a laptop with me unless I really need and at that point there are sufficient solutions available so get over it.
How about we ask for something more important like mms? Or the ability to attach more than one item to an email. How about some real desktop capabilities like downloading and saving files from the Internet and our emails? Or the ability to have more than four items in my dock or to change the orientation of my dock and the orientation of my email and sms when I'm reading or typing. Instead of just tryna make it a better phone how bout we ask for the features that make it a better convergence dvice?

By Davieboy at 12:21 PM ON 06/15/08

Haptic feedback aint that good. I have it on my Samsung phone and its a nice feature at first but doesn't always work and is ocassionally slow to respond to a touch. Couldn't agree more about the camera though!!

By DISaptment at 7:21 PM ON 06/22/08

Love the iPhone, hate the service. I can travel through the outback of Minnesota and Wisconsin with my Sprint phone in Digital Roam and never miss a call. Bought the iPhone 1.0 and after leaving any metropolitan area I got nothing. My job requires that I am available for 24 to 48 hours at a time via telephone while I am on call. The iPhone couldn't cut it so I returned it.

By BroLouieLLB1 at 2:44 AM ON 12/19/08

that is why i did not switch to iphone, it is cool, but you cant use it as a modem.


Leave a Comment


Type the characters you see in the picture above.

(Please be patient, it may take a moment for your comment to appear.)

DVICE continues below
Get the latest tech news
on your cellphone!
Text DVICE to 72434
DVICE on your iPhone
Follow DVICE on Twitter
Editor: Peter Pachal
editor@dvice.com
©2009, Syfy. All rights reserved.