The Syfy Online NetworkSCI FI WireDVICEFidgit

DVICE: We love technology. We want to know about it, write about it, and shake it till it breaks. Part of the Syfy Network, DVICE has a worldwide team of writers who constantly immerse themselves in the tech world, distilling the sometimes-excessive information out there to bring you only what you need to know.

Video
 

Related Sections: Video

Peer Review: Critics love Netflix's $100 Roku box, long for more content

netflixroku.jpg

Blockbuster hinted at a set-top box, but Netflix beat it to the punch this week, announcing an inexpensive little box that operates seamlessly with your pre-existing Netflix account. It's manufactured by Roku and costs $99. Any Netflix subscription over $9 a month qualifies for unlimited video streaming. So what's not to like? As with the Hulu launch, critics seemed to think that while the technology is there (and in both cases, at the right price), the amount of available content leaves something to be desired. Click Continue to read excerpts from reviews from around the web.

"If every piece of media in the Netflix catalog were streamable, this would be a 10 for sure."
"Textbook definition of a simple setup. Good video quality from streams. Box automatically upgrades as new software features become available. No cost above normal Netflix subscription… Just not as much content as we wish was available. , Wired

Meh. Wait 'till this box can do more than just Netflix
"If and when the Roku box serves up other streaming services it'll be a nice little node to stick on your TV to slurp up some free(ish) web media. Until then, it's probably for 'Netflix.com die-hards only,' a phrase I'd like to see more of." , Boing Boing Gadgets

Soon, Roku's features may be integrated into your TV
"Despite minor flaws, the Netflix player from Roku offers near-instant streams of movies without increasing your subscription cost. My sincere hope is that Netflix cribs from Apple's playbook and offers a wider Instant queue selection in the future… My guess is that eventually, the streaming feature will be part of Blu-ray players and TVs. But for now, the Netflix Player by Roku strikes me as a great value for early adopters and film addicts alike." PC Magazine

As long as you don't only like first run movies, it's great
"This is one of the most elegant and surprisingly usable dedicated devices I’ve seen in a long time. Unlike, say, the Kindle, everything here is almost perfect. As the literal incarnation of a web service, the Netflix Player by Roku is a true gem." , Crunchgear

It's flexible (take that, Apple TV)
"We were happy to see the presence of composite and S-Video jacks, as well an aspect ratio (standard or wide screen) toggle— which lets the Netflix Player connect to any old TV, not just HD set. (Apple TV can only connect to HDTVs.)" , CNet

It may be old content, but it's unlimited
"While appearing to have double the collection of Apple TV or Vudu, what do you get in Netflix's 10,000 movie collection? Basically, you get a lot of back catalog (classic movies) and a lot of TV shows (unheard of in rental situations!) right as they hit the market… The business model behind a flat rate unlimited streaming system is unheard of. Sure, they're taking a lot of older content, which is inherently cheaper. But think of it this way: For a nine-dollar-a-month account, you can hold off on buying older DVDs." , Gizmodo

Image was not impressive, though better than expected
"Personally, I found the image quality underwhelming… I saw minimal artifacts, but the image looked flat, with muted colors. Some standard def content was downright blurry: the opening credits for some films and television shows were difficult to read… Still, the image quality was better than I'd expected considering the Roku was outputting at 480p to a 50-inch Pioneer plasma television" , PC World

Easy enough for the grandparents
"It's pretty easy to learn to love this little hundred dollar bugger, even despite the fact that we need another set top box in our living room like we need a hole in the head. Sure, it's great that Netflix subscribers get a cheap, easy avenue for additional content to their TV, but the real beauty here is that this might actually be a streaming video box friendly enough to rival the Apple TV — or to give your folks." , Engadget

Almost perfect
"Is the Netflix Player, then, the movie box the world is waiting for? Not quite. It falls short on the age of its movies, the smallish selection of good ones and the not-quite-pristine video quality… But it comes darned close. For movie lovers who already subscribe to Netflix, at least, this one-time $100 expenditure is practically a no-brainer." , The New York Times


What do you think? Have you run out and bought one yet? As Netflix lovers, we're pretty excited…


Last Time: AT&T's Mobile TV service looks good from this Vu

 
Send-A-Friend
(3) Comments

Weebork:
I have the trial offer at Netflix. I've used some of their streaming movies and its adequate. It could be better an...More »


Comments

By dotanuki at 11:22 AM ON 05/25/08

I ran out and bought one.

So far it has lived up to expectations.

I love the ability to update my queue on Neflix from my laptop, and the update on the Roku with in 30 seconds.

Running it on a commcast internet connection does not seem to slow it down, and I have not seen any pauses or pixelation. Currently I am using the component connection and the picture is great. I can't wait to try the HDMI connection.

The only thing I would like to see is it do is upscale the TV programming.

By Traveler at 1:55 PM ON 05/25/08

An exciting product, but till they start offering HD w/5.1 I'll stick with NetFlix disks.

By Weebork at 3:22 PM ON 05/25/08

I have the trial offer at Netflix. I've used some of their streaming movies and its adequate. It could be better and that's the problem with having online movies: storage space. Just think of the size of the Netflix server farm would need to be to fit most or all of their DVDs, blueray or standard, for online streaming! For high quality, we're talking GBs of storage space per movie. HD is even larger. (That is, unless they use formats that compress things down, but this would be counter-intuitive to use in conjunction with HD which is supposed to be uncompressed).

Sure, HD streaming may come eventually, when monthly prices for data speeds required to use HD formats becomes affordable to most, but we're talking perhaps several more years for this to happen. The technology is there to have the speeds, Japan has shown this, but the infrastructure to get it all started is very expensive, especially for FIOS (fiber optics).


Leave a Comment


Type the characters you see in the picture above.

(Please be patient, it may take a moment for your comment to appear.)

DVICE continues below
Get the latest tech news
on your cellphone!
Text DVICE to 72434
DVICE on your iPhone
Follow DVICE on Twitter
Editor: Peter Pachal
editor@dvice.com
©2009, Syfy. All rights reserved.