The Syfy Online NetworkSCI FI WireDVICEFidgit

We love technology. We want to know about it, write about it, and shake it till it breaks. Part of the Syfy Network, DVICE has a worldwide team of writers who constantly immerse themselves in the tech world, distilling the sometimes-excessive information out there to bring you only what you need to know.

Video
 

Related Sections: Apple  PCs

Air clone, schm-air clone, Fujitsu P1620 goes above and beyond

p1620fuj.jpg

Put that credit card down for a second before dropping those big bucks on a super thin and very gimpy MacBook Air. Even after getting our thoughts on it and seeing some reasons you should buy one, it's time to take a step back and look at the big picture, and that picture includes one heck of an alternative from Fujitsu. The Fujitsu P1620 is a lightweight and small notebook that goes above and beyond the Air and the custom-built ModBook.

This laptop has a 1.2 GHz Core 2 Duo processor, compared to the 1.6 or 1.8 GHz on the Air. It also has 2GB of memory, a 100GB hard drive, Wi-Fi, SD slot, wired Ethernet and fingerprint reader.

The optional 32GB solid-state flash drive is only another $300, compared to the extra $1,000 required for the 64GB solid-state drive on the Air upgrade. One advantage the MacBook Air has is the 13.3-inch display, compared to the 9-inch display on the P1620, and the thinness factor. Then again the P1620 is also a tablet, and costs $50 less than the MacBook Air and a few hundred less than the keyboardless ModBook at $1,749. How about them apples, uh, Apple?

Fujitsu P1620, via Gadget Lab

CORRECTION: I mistakenly reported the price on the 64GB solid-state drive upgrade for the MacBook Air. It's now corrected. Sorry!

 
Send-A-Friend
(7) COMMENTS

Bennu:
I purchased the Macbook Air and found it to be fantastic. When I travel I can do all the work I need to without f...More »


Comments

By murray at 8:30 PM ON 01/18/08

Filing this one under weird comparisons. (And yes, the file is marked "Apples & oranges")

By TKen at 10:52 PM ON 01/18/08

Travis, please check your facts in this article. For the 64GB SSD on the MacBook Air, it's $999 to upgrade, not $1700. For an P1620 configured to match the Air (2GB memory, 80GB HD), you have to pay $2374. You can get the Air's faster CPU, optical drive, ethernet adapter, modem, airline adapter, remote, and a printer for $2,325. Plus, the biggest asset of the wireless notebook is battery life (5 hours (Air) vs. 3.5 (P1620)). So, 9 inch display, 1.2 GHz cpu, and shorter battery life at a higher cost is "above and beyond"? How about actually checking out Fujitsu's website and comparing costs instead of just posting a link to it and not repeating the sloppy journalism of other websites: http://www.engadget.com/2008/01/18/fujitsus-lifebook-p1620-is-lighter-than-macbook-air/.

By Andy Martin at 3:57 AM ON 01/19/08

@TKEN... you are so right. Going to Fuji's site and trying outfit one of these beasts to ahve as-near-as-possible specs to a MacBookAir it's interesting to notice that the $300 32GB flash drive option leaves the P1620 a little less than $300 below the same price as an Air with a 64 GB drive, meaning that if the P1620 HAD the same full capacity as an Air (64GB flash drive, 13" screen, >1.2GHZ cpu), well it would only be significantly more expensive than the Air.
Sure, the P1620 is cheaper... but only because it's cheaper design and construction. I'm sorry... a 8.9" screen? Why the *bleep* would you want an 8.9" screen on anything other than a glorified PDA?

By Amy at 3:39 AM ON 01/20/08

Also, when comparing to the ModBook you fail to address the fact that it is not just another tablet... but one with 512 levels of pressure sensitivity and one that is aimed at artists and designers... it's not MEANT to cater to the "ultra-portable" crowd. And if we're going to talk specs, the Modbook is available as a 2.2 Ghz Duo Core 2 processor and can be maxed out at a much bigger (and faster) hard drive as well as 4 gigs of RAM.

You're comparing Apples to Oranges here... and the Orange... er Fujitsu... as nice as it may be... isn't remotely the same type of machine as the ModBook.

By toontimer at 11:15 AM ON 02/21/08

I'm sensing a lot of Apple-bashing here and in other articles. Why do you hate Apple so much? Is anything introduced by Microsoft really any better? Vista anyone? What happened to objective reporting?

By bennu at 2:55 PM ON 03/06/08

I purchased the Macbook Air and found it to be fantastic. When I travel I can do all the work I need to without fail. Its Light weight, has 13.3 screen and a 5 hour battery life. I got the one with 1.8 gig Duo Core 2. I do think it was a little high in price but it wasn't enough to stop me from getting it. And as far as the optical drive who needs it. The fact I can use an optical drive on either a mac or PC is great. I however did get the superdrive for the Macbook Air I only used it twice and only to load 2 programs. If I thought about a little more I would most likely not have gotten the superdrive, But with that said I by far don't regret it. All in All I would give the Macbook Air a 10 out 10.

By Bennu at 2:56 PM ON 03/06/08

I purchased the Macbook Air and found it to be fantastic. When I travel I can do all the work I need to without fail. Its Light weight, has 13.3 screen and a 5 hour battery life. I got the one with 1.8 gig Duo Core 2. I do think it was a little high in price but it wasn't enough to stop me from getting it. And as far as the optical drive who needs it. The fact I can use an optical drive on either a mac or PC is great. I however did get the superdrive for the Macbook Air I only used it twice and only to load 2 programs. If I thought about a little more I would most likely not have gotten the superdrive, But with that said I by far don't regret it. All in All I would give the Macbook Air a 10 out 10.


Leave a Comment


Type the characters you see in the picture above.

(Please be patient, it may take a moment for your comment to appear.)

DVICE continues below
Get the latest tech news
on your cellphone!
Text DVICE to 72434
DVICE on your iPhone
Follow DVICE on Twitter
Editor: Peter Pachal
editor@dvice.com
©2010, Syfy. All rights reserved.