


With the arrival of the Sony PlayStation 3 (Friday) and Nintendo Wii (Saturday) later this week, it's the biggest time for video games since… well, since last fall when Microsoft's Xbox 360 arrived. But this year is actually more reminiscent of November 2001, when the Nintendo GameCube arrived just days following the original Xbox. But unlike five years ago, when the two systems were separated by only $100 (the GameCube was $200, while the Xbox was $300), we're looking at some major differences in price as well as system power and capabilities this time around. So how do the consoles stack up?
Last Friday two boxes arrived on my doorstep, and I spent the weekend immersed in some head-to-head playtime… er, testing. Check out my thoughts on both systems after the jump.
QUICK TAKE: PlayStation 3
HITS
Excellent interface, solid sound and graphics, same great PlayStation controller — only better!
MISSES
No HDMI cable included, only one controller included, bad choice of movie, high price point.
For that hefty price you get one wireless controller and a copy of the Blu-ray movie Talladega Nights starring Will Ferrell. It's been three days and the shrink-wrap remains on that movie, and will likely remain that way for a while. Of all the Blu-ray movies that could have been included, one must ponder the question, "Why this one?" What Sony didn't include (besides a second controller) was a game. So if you're lucky enough to get a PS3, be sure to grab a game or two, and then plan on picking up an HDMI cable, as Sony cheaped out in that department, too.
The system hooks up quickly, and the interface is similar to the one used on Sony's PlayStation Portable, which makes sharing of music, photos, and other files fairly simple. Clearly this is meant to be a machine that can do much more than run games. But before you can play the first game you need to — wait for it — upgrade the firmware. This requires a broadband connection, and it took me about 20 minutes total. Keep that in mind before you call over your buddies to play.
As a console the system is solid. Resistance: The Fall of Man was one of a few games I was able to play this weekend, and it delivered the goods. This game supports Dolby Digital surround sound and 720p resolution, easily making it the must-have killer app for the system. But while Sony could have thrown together a shooter just to show off the technical power, it actually crafted a game that could become a new franchise (much like Halo has become for the Xbox).
When it comes to Blu-ray you can't go wrong at $600. The PS3 is a much better Blu-ray player than the PS2 was a DVD player, and clearly this is what Sony was thinking when it delayed the release of the console to accommodate the Blu-ray drive. Now only if it could have included a better Blu-ray movie to show off the format!
QUICK TAKE: Wii
HITS
Controller adds a new dimension to gaming, good price point, Wii Sports included with the console.
MISSES
Limited online functions so far, no DVD playback.
The graphics on the Wii top out at 480p. When everyone else is looking to 1080p, this seems like an oversight. Worse still, there was no Wii-specific component-video cable provided, and with the release scheduled for Saturday the stores don't have them yet either. So I was stuck with 480i resolution for the weekend. This was tolerable but a little disappointing, too. Even when set to widescreen mode, many of the games still have the squarish 4:3 aspect ratio. Clearly someone is missing the point that consumers are actually adopting HDTVs.
The major innovation with the Wii is the motion-sensing controller. This two-piece device actually takes a bit of patience, and even then it can be a bit frustrating. The most annoying aspect of it is that you need to have a sensor bar located above or below your TV screen to track its movement. Hmm, suddenly the innovative controller seems a little less innovative. But gameplay-wise, the controller, once mastered, does put a new spin on the games. It remains a novelty, but does immerse you into what you're playing a little bit more than just lying on the couch all day. And maybe that's what this nation of sedentary gamers needs the most right now.
The most notable change with the Wii is that Nintendo is finally beginning to embrace the idea of an online community. The Nintendo Channels will let you download classic games. But it remains to be seen when Nintendo will enable online multiplayer gaming with the Wii.
Last week the HD DVD drive for the Xbox 360 arrived, and the system's big holiday game, Gears of War, has also made its debut. This one-two punch seems to have taken a bit of steam out of the Sony juggernaut. But we won't rule out Nintendo. Every time it looks like Mario has met his match, he manages to come back one more time!
Still want to play more? Come Check out our first takes on the specific games
for the Nintendo Wii and Sony PS3
By puzzleman65 at 10:59 PM ON 11/13/06
I am an Xbox man. I loved my Xbox and love my 360. What I don't understand with the 3 companies is how they can produce so few systems when they know that they are going to be in demand. Maybe that is what they planned all along. I am glad that Microsoft is coming out with a HD-DVD player, but for $ 200.00, will I get one. Probably not. And was really gets me is that I have to get a wireless adapter for my 360 to connect to the internet. Why didn't they just incorperate that into the system when it came out? Oh, I know. $$$$$$$$$
By Murcielago05 at 2:08 AM ON 11/14/06
I plan on getting a 360 mid next week, I'm glad that wifi isn't built in...since I have zero need for it, I hate paying for thing I wont use...which is one reason I'm going with MS over Sony...there forcing their movie format down are throats...and MS is offering an HD-DVD add-on, which is just for movies...not that I care, since I'm steering clear of the HD battle until a dual format player comes out.
BTW, I'm a little pissed at the new consoles release dates...out of all the weekends, they pick the one that I wont be home, because its opening weekend for deer hunting (SD)....booooyaaaa.
By xerephes at 7:31 AM ON 11/17/06
I'm a Playstation man myself. What I don't think that MS and Sony are thinking of is the $400 & $600 initial selling price! The common (or maybe not so common) gamer usually won't have that kind of money to buy a system. Whether or not the system has this feature or that add on, who cares. I now have to wait for hmmm...about a year for the price to go down to where it's affordable. That's just not right.
By gzam415 at 2:12 PM ON 11/17/06
I can't wait for the Wii, but mostly for the new Zelda, in my opinion the BEST game series ever. Sony actually isn't making any profit on the PS3, so don't expect the price to drop any time soon, they actually cost more to produce than they sell for. They expect to make up the difference on the sale of the games, which is why they floated the licensing ploy a few months ago.
Nintendo has always been my favorite system and, considering they'll be releasing 4 million by the end of the year in North America, getting one by the end of this year is totally doable.
I'm still waiting for MS's price point to drop before I invest in a 360.
By gothicshark at 8:56 PM ON 11/17/06
Xbox 360, PS3, Wii:
Xbox 360, is the budget minded gamers machine, solid and you don't have to buy it with the bells and whistles.
Wii, its Cheap and fun and great for kids, and the Hard core Nintendo fans will love it no matter what.
PS3, i think sony goofed it, I bet its solid, I'm sure its fun, but I don't want to pay 200 for a blue ray, I don't want it on my game system.
gothicshark:
Xbox 360, PS3, Wii: Xbox 360, is the budget minded gamers machine, solid and you don't have to buy it with the bel...More »